Best Burger in St. Augustine

The hub loves a good burger. He doesn’t want anything fancy–no bacon, triple cheese, special sauce. Just good beef, well cooked, in a bun that doesn’t look like it was sat on.

True confessions: our favorite burger in town was the single (me) or double (him) version that we used to enjoy at Five Guys Burgers and Fries. We’re from Baltimore originally, and Five Guys is a DC staple (the first restaurant opened outside the capitol). Now, granted…we may have convinced ourselves that the burgers were the best ever just because we loved their fries so much. But seriously, they had good burgers too (it’s just that there wasn’t a whole bag full of them!)

But once Five Guys closed earlier this year, we had to expand our choices. So now, when we get hungry for a burger, here is where we end up:

1. Gas. Funny name aside, Gas knows how to make people happy. Like a benedict burger–with a grass fed beef patty, topped with a fried egg. And a jalapeno popper burger, and a blackened blue cheese and bacon burger. PLUS, they all come with homemade chips on the side. As the sign in the front says–you don’t want to pass Gas when you come to St. Augustine. 9 Anastasia Blvd. 904.217.0326.

2. Burger Buckets. What’s not to love about a burger that comes in a bucket? All the sandwiches come in buckets here, but the burger is the king–they make the patties fresh each day, and you can tell. If you’re feeling dangerous, try their Kick the Bucket Burger, a 14″ monster with multiple patties, onions rings, fries, and more. (We’ve only seen it–we’ve never eaten it). BONUS–they deliver for free to the Bayfront Marin House. www.fudgebuckets.com. 3 Cordova Street. 904.342.5295.

3. Scarlett O’Hara’s. If you like your burgers classic, Scarlett’s has you covered. Their certified Angus burger is perfectly cooked, with a choice of cheddar, provolone, American or Swiss cheese. Not too hungry? Try it as a slider. www.scarlettoharas.net. 70 Hypolita. 904.824.6535.

4. O.C. White’s. What’s not to like about a place that makes good burgers, and has almost the same view of the Matanzas as we do? Nothing. Here’s what else you’ll like: their blue Hawaiian burger, with blue cheese crumbles and pineapple salsa. Want it plain? Order their pirate burger–and you’ll be a happy matey. www.ocwhitesrestaurant.com. 118 Avenida. 904.824.0808.

5. Back 40 Urban Café. I’m stretching the rules a little bit here, but I have to include their meatloaf sandwich. It’s thicker than my jaw actually opens (I often opt to eat it with a fork), but it has the brown sugar/ketchup sauce my mom used to make, and just the right amount of onions. www.back40cafe.com. 40 S Dixie Highway. 904.824.0227.

6. Village Inn. It seems like cheating to put a chain on this list, but sometimes–when it’s 1:00 am and you realize that you don’t have enough in your stomach to make tomorrow morning viable–the Village Inn is exactly what you need. It’s open all night, the hamburgers are always hot, and if you go on Wednesday night, you get free pie for dessert too. www.villageinn.com. 900 N Ponce de Leon. 904.824.4377.

 

2 thoughts on “Best Burger in St. Augustine

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>